hn-classics/_stories/1999/9237421.md

[Source](http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/1378/did-disneys-em-the-lion-king-em-rip-off-an-old-japanese-tv-series/ "Permalink to Did Disney’s The Lion King rip off an old Japanese TV series? – The Straight Dope")

# Did Disney’s The Lion King rip off an old Japanese TV series? – The Straight Dope

* [Home][2]
* [Message Boards][3]
* [Ask the Master][4]
* [Who is Cecil Adams?][5]
* [Archive][6]

![The Straight Dope][7]

Fighting ignorance since 1973. (It's taking longer than we thought.)

![The Straight Dope][7]

* [Home][2]
* [Message Boards][3]
* [Ask the Master][4]
* [Who is Cecil Adams?][5]
* [Archive][6]

## Fighting ignorance since 1973.  
(It's taking longer than we thought.)

* # Did Disney’s _The Lion King_ rip off an old Japanese TV series?

  
December 24, 1999 

> Dear Cecil:
> 
> While waxing nostalgic over our favorite cartoons from the 60s and 70s with some friends, we suddenly realized that Disney's _The Lion King_ bears a striking resemblance in plot and cast to the Japanese-made 60s TV series _Kimba the White Lion_ __(of which we can all remember every word of the theme song, by the way). To wit: (1) orphaned lion cub destined to be king (Kimba/Simba); (2) father who died in treacherous circumstances (Caesar/Mufasa); (3) annoying busybody bird (Polly/Zazu); (4) wise but eccentric baboon (Dan'l/Rafiki); (5) cute girlfriend cub (Kitty/Nala); (6) villainous hyenas who are always trying to take over. So what's the straight dope? Is Disney's hit really just a cheap rip-off? I have never seen this issue addressed in print and look to you to correct this injustice.
> 
> Dr. M.G., via AOL 

![][8]

Illustration by Slug Signorino 

Cecil replies: 

Well, it wasn’t a _cheap_ rip-off — have you been to a first-run movie lately? You also missed a few other parallels: (7) name similarity: Kimba/Simba (duh); (8) evil Japanese lion, Claw, with one eye versus evil Disney lion, Scar, with scar over one eye; (9) little lion looks up to see the ghost of his father in the clouds; (10) heroic pose of lion on jutting rock. Item number 10 is particularly striking — see [www.cs.in diana.edu/hyplan/tanaka/Tezuka_Disney/Tezuka_Disney.html][9].

A coincidence here and there I could see. But ten? When _The Lion King_ came out in 1994, a lot of people concluded that Disney — so zealous in defending its own intellectual property that it once demanded removal of Mickey and Minnie Mouse images from a day-care center — might have appropriated someone else’s.

_Kimba the White Lion_ was the work of legendary Japanese manga (comic book) artist Tezuka Osamu, who also created _Astroboy_. Originally called _The Jungle Emperor_, the white lion’s adventures appeared in print during the early 50s and were made into a weekly TV series that aired on NBC starting in 1966. The show’s 52 half-hour episodes could be seen in syndication until the late 70s and are now available on video.

When _The Lion King_ opened in Japan, the uncredited Kimba parallels caused an uproar. More than 1,100 Japanese manga and anime (animation) artists and fans signed a petition asking Disney to acknowledge its debt to Tezuka. Disney refused, saying that the similarities were coincidental and that it had had no knowledge of Kimba.

Not true, investigation revealed. Of eight production people for _The Lion King_ contacted by the _San Francisco Chronicle_, three admitted familiarity with the series. But virtually everyone involved denied Tezuka’s influence, saying the real inspirations were Bambi and Hamlet (you know, prince avenges father’s murder by evil usurper). They claimed the parallels were an inevitable result of working with similar material, and in fact the two stories are quite different in many respects.

They haven’t budged on that story since — and I’m not just talking about Disney brass. Most animators for _The Lion King_ are still with Disney and have to clear their comments with the head office, but I was able to reach Tom Sito, the head of the animators’ union. He worked on storyboards for_ The Lion King_ but is now directing for Warner Brothers. “Believe me when I say that this Kimba/Lion King parallel is a nonstory,” Sito told me. “I have no vested interest in defending Disney. It just never came up. We worked for months on the story and I remember the anime show from my childhood, but honestly, no one to my knowledge ever made the connection.

“We were more than halfway through production with most of the story locked when one animator found a Kimba comic with a setting that looked very close to Pride Rock. He posted it and we were all very amused by the similarities but none of us felt we were ripping it off.”

But Tom, I said, making an animated film is a collaborative process. You throw out ideas, dredge up dimly recalled stuff from your youth — and how many animated productions about lions have there been? It’d be only natural to lift an idea from Kimba and not remember where you’d seen it. What’s more, none of the younger animators had seen the Japanese show, so there’d be no one at the table saying, No, can’t do that, been done. One source quoted by the _Chronicle_, in fact, said Tezuka’s influence may have been “subliminal.”

Sito didn’t buy it. Think Hamlet, he said. “Zazu is Polonius, Scar is Claudius, Rafiki the Shakespearean fool. The father in the clouds is the ghost king appearing on the battlements — it looks more impressive in the clouds than a ghost walking through the weeds. The one-eyed Japanese villain is an iconographic favorite that appears in dozens of anime and manga stories; it would be hard to base a court case on that one.” Sito conceded that animated films are collaborative but said professional pride prevents animators from knowingly ripping off others.

A reasonable argument. But you be the judge.

Cecil Adams

Send questions to Cecil via [ cecil@straightdope.com. ][10]

### _Related_

[Comment on this Column][11]

### [ Join Our Mailing List! ][12]

[Get weekly column reminders][12]

### Trending Threads

* [How to be hideous: the right wing tries to discredit the Parkland school shooting survivors][13]
* [I solved the gun control problem.][14]
* [Democrats push to make gun control a 2018 issue][15]
* [My wife has died.][16]
* [Trump's ongoing collusion][17]
* [Is the exact amount of money Clinton campaign paid to Russian operatives known?][18]
* [Why didn't Russians stop hacking US elections, after Obama begged Putin to stop it?][19]
* [Billy Graham dies at 99][20]
* [Hey Bernie, go to hell and take all of your Bros with you][21]
* [Read 

a random Straight Dope column][22]
* [

Learn 

about Cecil Adams, the world's smartest human ][23]
* [

Ask 

Cecil a question ][4]

### Site Info

Send questions for Cecil Adams to: [cecil@straightdope.com][10]

Send comments about this website to: [webmaster@straightdope.com][24]

[Terms of Use / Privacy Policy][25]

[Advertise on the Straight Dope!][26] Your direct line to thousands of the smartest, hippest people on the planet, plus a few total dipsticks.

Publishers – interested in subscribing to the Straight Dope? Write to: [sdsubscriptions@chicagoreader.com][27].

Find us in the [Chicago Reader][28].

### Menu

* [Home][2]
* [Message Boards][3]
* [Ask the Master][4]
* [Who is Cecil Adams?][5]
* [Archive][6]

© 2018 STM Reader, LLC.  
Powered by [WordPress.com VIP][29]

[1]: http://pixel.quantserve.com/pixel/p-nbVcwx1YE9bmV.gif
[2]: http://www.straightdope.com/
[3]: https://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/
[4]: https://www.straightdope.com/ask-the-master/
[5]: https://www.straightdope.com/who-is-cecil-adams/
[6]: https://www.straightdope.com/archive/
[7]: https://www.straightdope.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/the-straight-dope-logo-1.png
[8]: https://www.straightdope.com/wp-content/uploads/art/1999/991224.gif?w=300
[9]: http://www.cs.indiana.edu/hyplan/tanaka/Tezuka_Disney/Tezuka_Disney.html
[10]: mailto:cecil%40straightdope.com
[11]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/forumdisplay.php?f=1
[12]: http://link.straightdopemail.com/join/5q6/newslettersignup
[13]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=849650
[14]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=849621
[15]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=849625
[16]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=849715
[17]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=849637
[18]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=849682
[19]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=849677
[20]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=849716
[21]: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=849772
[22]: https://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/376/how-were-the-high-pitched-voices-of-the-chipmunks-created/ "How were the high-pitched voices of the Chipmunks created?"
[23]: https://www.straightdope.com/who-is-this-man-called-cecil-adams/
[24]: mailto:webmaster%40straightdope.com
[25]: http://straightdope.com/terms-of-useprivacy-policy/
[26]: https://www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/ReaderDisplayinformation/Page
[27]: mailto:sdsubscriptions%40chicagoreader.com
[28]: https://www.chicagoreader.com/
[29]: https://vip.wordpress.com/?utm_source=vip_powered_wpcom&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=VIP%20Footer%20Credit&utm_term=www.straightdope.com