14 KiB
created_at | title | url | author | points | story_text | comment_text | num_comments | story_id | story_title | story_url | parent_id | created_at_i | _tags | objectID | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2014-06-05T13:50:13.000Z | Selection bias and bombers (2008) | http://www.johndcook.com/blog/2008/01/21/selection-bias-and-bombers/ | awjr | 91 | 18 | 1401976213 |
|
7851927 |
Selection bias example with WWII bombers
(832) 422-8646
Selection bias and bombers
Posted on 21 January 2008 by John
During WWII, statistician Abraham Wald was asked to help the British decide where to add armor to their bombers. After analyzing the records, he recommended adding more armor to the places where there was no damage!
This seems backward at first, but Wald realized his data came from bombers that survived. That is, the British were only able to analyze the bombers that returned to England; those that were shot down over enemy territory were not part of their sample. These bombers’ wounds showed where they could afford to be hit. Said another way, the undamaged areas on the survivors showed where the lost planes must have been hit because the planes hit in those areas did not return from their missions.
Wald assumed that the bullets were fired randomly, that no one could accurately aim for a particular part of the bomber. Instead they aimed in the general direction of the plane and sometimes got lucky. So, for example, if Wald saw that more bombers in his sample had bullet holes in the middle of the wings, he did not conclude that Nazis liked to aim for the middle of wings. He assumed that there must have been about as many bombers with bullet holes in every other part of the plane but that those with holes elsewhere were not part of his sample because they had been shot down.
Categories : Statistics
Tags : Probability and Statistics
Bookmark the permalink
Post navigation
Previous PostRepairing tumors
Next PostC# verbatim strings vs. PowerShell here-strings
42 thoughts on “Selection bias and bombers”
-
Pingback: Best early blog posts — The Endeavour
-
Ling
So is the assumption of random firing justified?
- John
Ling, I think the random firing assumption was justified at the time, given the state of technology. The standard error may have been larger than the size of an airplane.
- Speedmaster
Fantastic example.
- Eugene
Thanks, interesting story!
- Alfredo
Can you cite the source of this excellent example?
-
Pingback: The Importance of Selection Effects « Daniel J. Smith
-
Pingback: The Importance of Selection Effects — Marginal Revolution
-
Rafael
Wald, Abraham. (1943). A Method of Estimating Plane Vulnerability Based on Damage of Survivors.
http://cna.org/sites/default/files/research/0204320000.pdf
- John Thacker
Alfredo:
Here’s a reprint of one of his papers on the subject, and here’s another source.
However, while I’ve heard this story many time before, I had not heard it claimed that he did this for the British, but rather for the US Navy.
-
Pingback: Thinking Statistically | Delightfully Distinctive COLRS
-
Pingback: The Spamlist! » The Importance of Selection Effects
-
Alfredo
Thanks. This is good stuff as teaching material.
-
Pingback: Selection effects » Manlyisms
-
Pingback: Statistics in a time of war | Blog of Leonid Mamchenkov
-
Pingback: Selection Effects « Marc Gawley
-
Pingback: Can selection bias shoot down an argument? « The Melbourne Urbanist
I thought that was beautiful, and something that should be a part of basic education for everybody. How many decisions are poorly made because of the problem of silent evidence? This plagues everything from our social lives to government policy, and as a species it’s about time we got over this.
-
Suzie
Wait, so what were the final results? Did a higher %age of bombers come back after the fleet was fitted with the armor in Wald’s recommended areas?
-
Pingback: More on Democratic Consolidation and Time « Dart-Throwing Chimp
-
Pingback: DiSH lab blog » Blog Archive » A neat science riddle – can you solve it?
-
Pingback: Selection Bias and WWII Bombers | ≈42
-
Pingback: Brian’s Links 20 October 2011: Carnivory, Science, and Art « TheMoralMindfield
-
Pingback: On Bias and Statistics « Tropewell
-
Pingback: On Bias and Statistics « Tropewell
-
Pingback: A Few Random Morning Links … | The Pretense of Knowledge
Dan Meyer did a nice version of this for the high school crowd.
http://blog.mrmeyer.com/?p=507
Really nice graphic he created to go with the material.
-
Pingback: Success » Diigo Links (weekly)
-
Pingback: 7 Quick Takes (9/23/11)
-
Pingback: Military intelligence from serial numbers | John D. Cook
-
Ronald Chappell
Cute statistical study but also suffers from randomness bias. Armor the most vulnerable points; fuel, controls and cockpit, engines etc. Then apply statistics to the rest if you have any weight budget left.
- John
I believe the point of the study was to determine what the most vulnerable parts were.
-
Pingback: TWiV 340: No shift, measles
-
Pingback: Second languages and selection bias
-
Pingback: TWiV 340: No shift, measles | This Week in Virology
-
Pingback: The birthday problem | Datant
-
Toph Tucker
I am commenting years later because this is so good. I only came across it more recently and now I cite it to people all the time. I am not yet at the point where I can intuitively spot the pattern in action, but I hope to get there. I reckon the world is full of people solving the most survivable problems and ignoring the problems that remove their victims from the sample.
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Comment
Notify me of followup comments via e-mail
Name *
Email *
Website
Search for:
John D. Cook, PhD
Latest Posts
- Fibonacci / Binomial coefficient identity
- Painless project management
- New animation feature for exponential sums
- Quantifying normal approximation accuracy
- Ordinary Potential Polynomials
Categories
CategoriesSelect CategoryBusinessClinical trialsComputingCreativityGraphicsMachine learningMathMusicPowerShellPythonScienceSoftware developmentStatisticsTypographyUncategorized
| ----- | | | Subscribe via email | | | Subscribe via RSS | | | Monthly newsletter |
John D. Cook
© All rights reserved.
Search for: