85 KiB

Raw Blame History

created_at

title

url

author

points

story_text

comment_text

num_comments

story_id

story_title

story_url

parent_id

created_at_i

_tags

objectID

2014-04-28T16:04:28.000Z

Tolkien Snubs a German Publisher Asking for Proof of His “Aryan Descent” (1938)

http://www.openculture.com/2014/04/j-r-r-tolkien-snubs-a-german-publisher.html

arnauddri

112

1398701068

story

author_arnauddri

story_7660828

7660828

Source

J.R.R. Tolkien Snubs a German Publisher Asking for Proof of His "Aryan Descent" (1938) | Open Culture

J.R.R. Tolkien Snubs a German Publisher Asking for Proof of His "Aryan Descent" (1938) | Open Culture #currentMedia{display:none} @media only screen and (min-width:2000px) { #ExtraItem{display:hidden} .middle_sidebar{display:block-inline!important;width:20%} .r_sidebar{display:block-inline!important;width:24%} .contentmiddle{width:54%} } @media only screen and (max-width:1000px){ /* #ExtraItem{display:hidden} .middle_sidebar{display:block-inline!important;width:20%} .r_sidebar{display:block-inline!important;width:18%} .contentmiddle{width:60%} / .r_sidebar{display:block-inline!important;width:22%} } / First modification: TUrn on top or bottom / @media only screen and (min-width:927px){ /when viewport is larger than 927 turn on left, hide bottom logo/ .left {display:block !important; min-height:90px !important;} /.right{float:right !important; margin: 0 0% 0 0%;} */ .right {min-height:90px;} .bottom {display:none !important;} #navbar{width:100% !important;} } @media only screen and (max-width:938px){ /*when less than 867, turn on bottom */ .left {display:none !important;} .right{float:none !important; margin: 0 auto!important; min-height:55px; } .bottom {display:block !important; background-position-y:top !important;} } /*step 2: set proper logo for larger sizes */ @media only screen and (min-width:1170px){ /*larger than 1130---set .right size for large header */ .left{background: url("//cdn2.openculture.com/wp-content/themes/openculture_v4a/images/open-culture-horizontal-logo-with-tagline.svg") no-repeat !important; min-height:90px !important;} .right{width:740px ; margin: 0 2% 0 1%; text-align:right !important;} } @media only screen and (min-width:939px) and (max-width:1169px) { /*right ad, horizontal logo / .right{width:740px ; margin: 0 2% 0 1%; text-align:right !important;} .left{ background: url("//cdn2.openculture.com/wp-content/themes/openculture_v4a/images/open-culture-stacked-logo.svg") no-repeat !important; min-height:70px; background-position-x:center !important; } #clearfixheader{margin-top:.8rem !important;} } @media only screen and (min-width:814px) and (max-width:938px) { / right ad, stacked logo / .right{width:740px ; margin: 0 2% 0 1% !important; text-align:right !important;} .left{ background: url("//cdn2.openculture.com/wp-content/themes/openculture_v4a/images/open-culture-stacked-logo.svg") no-repeat !important; min-height:70px; background-position-x:center !important;} #clearfixheader{margin-top:2.8rem !important;} } / step 3 resize top ad / / sizes are: 728 x 90, 468x 60, 320x100 */ /*ads to right / @media only screen and (max-width:813px) and (min-width:768px){ / below 813, reduce right size for miniheader / .right{width:500px; text-align:center !important;} } / ads below */ @media only screen and (max-width:768px) and (min-width:721px){ /*ipad portrait ad on top; banner above / .right{width:768px;float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center !important;} } / cutoff for 728 AD at around 760 */ @media only screen and (max-width:720px)and (min-width:620px){ /*smaller ad */ #cleafixheader{height:40px !important;} .right{width:500px;float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center !important;} } @media only screen and (max-width:620px){ /*ipad portrait ad on top; banner above */ .right{width:500px;float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center !important;} } @media only screen and (max-width:460px){ /*reduce right size for mobileheader */ .right{width:400px;float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center !important;} } @media only screen and (max-width:360px){ /*reduce right size for mobileheader / .right{width:360px;float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center !important;} } @media only screen and (max-width:320px){ /reduce right size for mobileheader / .right{width:320px !important;float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center; max-width:320px !important;;} /#headermasterwrapper {height:80px !important} / } /Step 5 aesthetic tweaks, including column width changes/ @media only screen and (min-width: 1200px) { body { margin-top:1rem !important;} } @media only screen and (max-width:1024px) and (min-width:930px){ body { _font-size:88%; margin-top: 15px;} ul li#K-12{display:inline} .contentmiddle{width:54%!important} #clearfixheader{ margin-top:30px !important;} #ad_logo_wrapper { margin-left:.2rem; margin-top: 4rem !important;} #navbar {margin-top: -2rem !important;width:100%;} #ad_logo_wrapper {margin: 0 3% 0 3% !important; width:93% !important;} .contentwrapper {width: 94% !important; margin: 6px 1rem 0 1rem !important; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} } @media only screen and (max-width:929px) and (min-width:890px){ #ad_logo_wrapper {margin-left:2% !important; margin-right:2% !important; width:96% !important;} #clearfixheader{ margin-top:65px !important;} .contentmiddle{width:64% !important;} .middle_sidebar{width:34% !important;} } @media only screen and (max-width:891px) and (min-width:821px){ / less than 891 px, more than 821, run all three ads / .contentmiddle{width:64% !important;} .middle_sidebar{width:34% !important;} html{margin-top:45px;;} #clearfixheader{ margin-top:60px !important;} / #wrap{margin-top:100px !important;}/ / .left{background: url("/wp-content/themes/openculture_v3a/images/big_white_logo.png") no-repeat !important; min-width:60px !important;} / #ad_logo_wrapper {margin-left:1% !important; margin-right:1% !important; width:98% !important;} .contentwrapper {width:94% !important; margin: 6px 2% 0 2%!important; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} } @media only screen and (max-width:814px)and (min-width:740px){ / less than 820, less than 740, push right sidebar down with wide middle sidebar / / this is ipad portrait mode / / .r_sidebar{display:none!important} / html{margin-top:40px;;} .contentmiddle{width:66% !important} .middle_sidebar{width:34% !important} #ad_logo_wrapper {margin-left:2% !important; margin-right:2% !important; width:96% !important;} .contentwrapper {width:94% !important; margin: 1.5rem 0rem 0 2rem !important; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} #clearfixheader{ margin-top:30px !important;} } @media only screen and (max-width:739px)and (min-width:569px){ /ipad portrait =768 / html{font-size:70%; margin-top:30px !important;} .r_sidebar{display:none!important} .contentmiddle{width:62%!important} .middle_sidebar{width:30% !important} .contentwrapper {width:94% !important; margin: 0px 3% 0 3% !important;} #navbar {margin-top: 4rem !important;} #clearfixheader { margin-bottom: 2rem !important; margin-top:20px !important;} #ad_logo_wrapper {margin-left:4% !important; margin-right:4% !important; width:96% !important;} / #wrap{margin-top:20px !important;}/ .middle_sidebar{border-right:solid 0px #fff!important} .right{float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center !important;} } @media only screen and (max-width:568px)and (min-width:536px){ / iphone 6 landscape / /h1{font-size:1.3rem} / html{font-size:72%; margin-top:40px !important;} .contentmiddle{width:100%!important;} .middle_sidebar{display:none!important;} .r_sidebar{display:none!important} / #wrap{margin-top:30px !important}}/ #navbar {margin-top: -1.2rem !important } #clearfixheader { margin-bottom: -1.4rem !important; margin-top:20px !important; } .right{width:100%;float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center !important;} #ad_logo_wrapper {margin-left:2% !important; margin-right:2% !important; width:96% !important; } .contentwrapper {width:96% !important; margin: 1rem 3% 0 3% !important; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} } @media only screen and (max-width:535px){ / */ /h1{font-size:1.3rem} / html{font-size:64%; margin-top:0px !important;} .contentmiddle{width:100%!important;} .middle_sidebar{display:none!important;} .r_sidebar{display:none!important} / #wrap{margin-top:30px !important}}/ #navbar {margin-top: 1.8rem !important;} #clearfixheader { margin-bottom: -1rem !important; display: inline-flex; height: 8px; margin-top: 20px !important;;} .bottom {min-height:40px !important;} .right{float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center !important;} #ad_logo_wrapper {margin-left:2% !important; margin-right:2% !important; width:96% !important; } .contentwrapper {width:96% !important; margin: 1rem 2% 0 2% !important; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} } @media only screen and (max-width:480px){ /h1{font-size:1.2rem;} / html{font-size:64%; margin-top:3rem;} .contentmiddle{width:96%} .middle_sidebar{display:none!important} .r_sidebar{display:none!important} #wrap{padding-top:5px !important} #navbar {margin: 2.4rem auto !important;} #ad_logo_wrapper { margin-left:.2rem !important; margin-top: 4.4rem !important;} #clearfixheader { margin-bottom: -1.3rem; !important; display: inline-flex; height: 8px;} .contentwrapper {width:95% !important; margin: -1.4rem 3% 0 3% !important; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} @media only screen and (max-width:414px){ /h1{font-size:1.2rem;} / html{font-size:64%; margin-top:1rem;} .contentmiddle{width:96%} .middle_sidebar{display:none!important} .r_sidebar{display:none!important} #wrap{padding-top:5px !important} #headermasterwrapper {margin-top: -16px !important;} #navbar {margin: 12px auto !important;} #ad_logo_wrapper { margin-left:.4rem !important;} #clearfixheader { margin-bottom: -1.3rem; !important} .contentwrapper {width:95% !important; margin: -1.4rem 3% 0 3% !important; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} .right{float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center;} / #ad_logo_wrapper,#navbar {margin-left:0%; margin-right:0%;} .contentwrapper {width:100%; margin: 12px 1% 0 1%; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} / } @media only screen and (max-width:375px){ / iphone6 375 portrait / html{font-size:80%; margin-top:1rem;} #wrap{padding-top:0px !important;} .contentmiddle{width:96% !important} .middle_sidebar{display:none!important} .r_sidebar{display:none!important} /pull navbar up to logo / #headermasterwrapper {margin-top: -28px !important;} #navbar {margin: 2rem 8px 0 0px !important ; width: 100% !important;} #ad_logo_wrapper { margin-top:3.3rem; margin-left:.3rem !important;} #clearfixheader { margin-bottom: -1.3rem !important;} .contentwrapper {width:96%!important; margin: -1.4rem 3% 0 3% !important; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} .right{float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center;} } @media only screen and (max-width:320px){ / iphone5 320 portrait / html{font-size:64%; margin-top:-1rem !important;} #wrap{padding-top:0px !important;} .contentmiddle{width:95% !important;} .middle_sidebar{display:none!important} .r_sidebar{display:none!important} #headermasterwrapper {margin-top: -28px !important;} /pull navbar up to logo / #ad_logo_wrapper { margin-top: 1rem; margin-left: .3rem !important;} #navbar { width: 100% !important; margin-top:-.8rem !important; } #clearfixheader { margin-bottom: -2rem !important;} .contentwrapper {width:96%!important; margin: -.1rem 3% 0 4% !important; _margin: 12px 7% 0 7%;} .right{float:none !important; margin: 0 auto; text-align:center;} } @media (max-width:1024px){#currentMedia{max-width:1024px}} @media (max-width:768px){#currentMedia{max-width:768px}} @media (max-width:720px){#currentMedia{max-width:720px}} @media(max-width:420px){#currentMedia{max-width:420px}} // // // var ajaxurl = 'http://www.openculture.com/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php'; {"@context":"http://schema.org","@type":"WebSite","@id":"#website","url":"http://www.openculture.com/","name":"Open Culture","potentialAction":{"@type":"SearchAction","target":"http://www.openculture.com/?s={search_term_string}","query-input":"required name=search_term_string"}}{"@context":"http://schema.org","@type":"Organization","url":"http://www.openculture.com/2014/04/j-r-r-tolkien-snubs-a-german-publisher.html","sameAs":["https://plus.google.com/+openculture/"],"@id":"#organization","name":"Open Culture, LLC","logo":"//cdn8.openculture.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/28004000/open_culture_white.jpg"} .mashsb-count {color:#cccccc;} [class^="mashicon-"], .onoffswitch-label, .onoffswitch2-label, .onoffswitch { border-radius: 10px; }[class^="mashicon-"] .text, [class=" mashicon-"] .text{ text-indent: -9999px !important; line-height: 0px; display: block; } [class^="mashicon-"] .text:after, [class=" mashicon-"] .text:after { content: "" !important; text-indent: 0; font-size:13px; display: block !important; } [class^="mashicon-"], [class=" mashicon-"] { width:25%; text-align: center !important; } [class^="mashicon-"] .icon:before, [class=" mashicon-"] .icon:before { float:none; margin-right: 0; } .mashsb-buttons a{ margin-right: 3px; margin-bottom:3px; min-width: 0; width: 41px; } .onoffswitch, .onoffswitch-inner:before, .onoffswitch-inner:after .onoffswitch2, .onoffswitch2-inner:before, .onoffswitch2-inner:after { margin-right: 0px; width: 41px; line-height: 41px; } @media only screen and (max-width: 568px){ .mashsb-buttons a { width: 24px; } } @media only screen and (max-width: 568px){ [class^="mashicon-"] .text, [class=" mashicon-"] .text { display: none; } } / / / / / / //.car-collapse .car-yearmonth { cursor: s-resize; } / */ var _sf_startpt=(new Date()).getTime()

[J.R.R. Tolkien Snubs a German Publisher Asking for Proof of His "Aryan Descent" (1938)][10]

in History, [Literature][11] | April 28th, 2014 [16 Comments][12]

16.4k

[Facebook][13][Twitter][14][Reddit][15]

[Subscribe][16][Google][17][Whatsapp][18][Pinterest][16][Digg][19][Linkedin][20][Stumbleupon][21][Vk][22][Print][23][Delicious][24][Buffer][25][Pocket][26][Xing][27][Tumblr][28][Mail][29][Yummly][30][Telegram][31][Flipboard][32]

![J R R Tolkien][33]

As you'd expect from a man who had to create, in painstaking detail, all the races that populate Middle-Earth, [J.R.R. Tolkien][34] had little time for simple racism. He had especially little time for the highest-profile simple racism of his day, the wave of anti-Jewish sentiment on which Adolf Hitler and the Nazi party rode straight into the Second World War. His first novel [The Hobbit][35], predecessor to the [Lord of the Rings][36] trilogy, first appeared in 1937, a time when the situation in Europe had turned ominous indeed, and would get far uglier still. It didn't take long after the book's initial success for Berlin publisher Rütten & Loening to express their interest in putting out a German edition, but first — in observance, no doubt, of the Third Reich's dictates — they asked for proof of Tolkien's "Aryan descent." The author drafted two replies, the less civil of which reads as follows:

25 July 1938
20 Northmoor Road, Oxford

Dear Sirs,

Thank you for your letter. I regret that I am not clear as to what you intend by arisch. I am not of Aryan extraction: that is Indo-Iranian; as far as I am aware none of my ancestors spoke Hindustani, Persian, Gypsy, or any related dialects. But if I am to understand that you are enquiring whether I am of Jewish origin, I can only reply that I regret that I appear to have no ancestors of that gifted people. My great-great-grandfather came to England in the eighteenth century from Germany: the main part of my descent is therefore purely English, and I am an English subject — which should be sufficient. I have been accustomed, nonetheless, to regard my German name with pride, and continued to do so throughout the period of the late regrettable war, in which I served in the English army. I cannot, however, forbear to comment that if impertinent and irrelevant inquiries of this sort are to become the rule in matters of literature, then the time is not far distant when a German name will no longer be a source of pride.

Your enquiry is doubtless made in order to comply with the laws of your own country, but that this should be held to apply to the subjects of another state would be improper, even if it had (as it has not) any bearing whatsoever on the merits of my work or its sustainability for publication, of which you appear to have satisfied yourselves without reference to my Abstammung.

I trust you will find this reply satisfactory, and

remain yours faithfully,

J. R. R. Tolkien

"I have in this war a burning private grudge against that ruddy little ignoramus Adolf Hitler," Tolkien wrote to his son Michael three years later, by which time the war had reached a new height. "Ruining, perverting, misapplying, and making for ever accursed, that noble northern spirit, a supreme contribution to Europe, which I have ever loved, and tried to present in its true light." He had already faced German forces in combat during his service in World War I, and had almost became one of World War II's codebreakers after the British Foreign Office's cryptographic department brought the possibility to him in early 1939. He did not, in the event, participate directly in the conflict, but he did leave behind an uncommonly eloquent paper trail documenting his stance of unambiguous antipathy for the Nazis and their ideology.

For more such fascinating perspectives vouchsafed to history through the mail, do have a look at [Letters of Note: An Eclectic Collection of Correspondence Deserving of a Wider Audience][37], the brand new book from the site of the same name. Tolkien's letter above [comes from it][38], as do many of the illuminating missives we've featured here before — and, without a doubt, those we'll continue to feature in the future.

Want to download a Tolkien audio book for free? Start a [30-day free trial with Audible.com][39] and you can download one of his major works in unabridged format. You can keep the book regardless of whether you continue with their great program or not. There are no strings attached.

Related Content:

["The Tolkien Professor" Presents Three Free Courses on The Lord of the Rings][40]

[Discover J.R.R. Tolkien's Personal Book Cover Designs for The Lord of the Rings Trilogy][41]

[C.S. Lewis' Prescient 1937 Review of The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien: It "May Well Prove a Classic"][42]

[Discover J.R.R. Tolkien's Personal Book Cover Designs for The Lord of the Rings Trilogy][41]

Colin Marshall hosts and produces [Notebook on Cities and Culture][43] and writes essays on cities, language, Asia, and men's style. He's at work on a book about Los Angeles, [A Los Angeles Primer][44]. Follow him on Twitter at [@colinmarshall][45] or on [Facebook][46].

16.4k

[Facebook][13][Twitter][14][Reddit][15]

by [Colin Marshall][47] | [Permalink][48] | Comments (16) |

Support Open Culture

We're hoping to rely on our loyal readers rather than erratic ads. To support Open Culture's continued operation, please consider making a donation. We thank you!
![][49]

Comments (16)

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Tim says:

[ April 29, 2014 at 6:42 am][50]

A brilliant reply from one of the most gifted writers of the 20th C. Thanks for sharing it with us.

[Reply][51]

Cody says:

[ April 29, 2014 at 11:44 am][52]

I think this post was wasted. Tolkien was, of course, not racist and hated the Nazis, but this was already well understood (even Wikipedia deals with this at length). What Tolkien’s position should show us is that his hatred of Nazism went beyond the current pop culture-informed assumptions. Tolkien knew, as we should, that the politicized, warped, Manichean "choice" between the construal of Germanness as GOOD because it is war-like and white supremacist (the Nazi’s view) vs. the construal of Germanness as BAD because it is war-like and white supremacist (the Anglo-American view), is a false choice.
Germanness and the connotations around it cannot and should not be so reduced. Tolkien saw that the issue is more complicated and, while there is no reason whatsoever to promote anything German as being naturally superior, that which derives from a Germanic sensibility can be wonderful, but is seen today through a very distorted lens (which makes it easy to hate or dismiss). That is the important lesson here: we love deriding the Germans, though cheaply and from misunderstanding. Tolkien was decent and sophisticated enough to see, even though he was immersed lifelong in the doctrines of the British Empire, that our very correct rejection of the values of Nazism should not then, wrongheadedly, extend to a rejection of Germanness.

[Reply][53]

Doug says:

[ April 29, 2014 at 12:08 pm][54]

le reddit army is here!

[Reply][55]

RageMojo says:

[ April 29, 2014 at 1:04 pm][56]

Cody, you are off base and out of context. This was before WW2, so it was before he would have been so staunchly anti Nazi. This is before anyone but german jews were anti Nazi.

[Reply][57]

James says:

[ April 29, 2014 at 2:37 pm][58]

Ragemojo, I assure you, the Nazi’s were not uniformly well regarded before WWII either. The NSDAP (the Nazi’s) were well understood to be both totalitarian and expansionistic. Tolkein’s politics were largely formed during his experiences during WWI. He was pro agrarianism, anti industrialization, anti-authoritarian. He found the tendencies the Nazi’s exhibited in the 30’s to be worrying and orc-like.

But he was also careful with that comparison. He certainly compared Orcs to Nazi’s, he specifically ruled out comparing Orcs to Germans (or any other real race, for that matter.)

[Reply][59]

Zorg says:

[ April 29, 2014 at 2:53 pm][60]

I have always been (since I first read it in 1973 anyway) troubled by the evident racism in Lord of the Rings.

It really shocks me to hear people say that Tolkien was not racist OF COURSE (I add emphasis to the shocking part of course). Racism is not necessarily uttered or practiced with the over-the-top rantings of a Hitler. Utterances may well seem racist in one era or culture that would seem tame in another.

For example, Tolkien’s letter refers to the Jews as a gifted people. That strikes me as a racist remark. I don’t want to hold Jews higher than anyone else any more than I want them to be treated worse than anyone else.

Throughout the Lord of the Rings it seems to me that a person or creature’s alliance with good or evil is frequently a matter of race. Sauron’s dark-skinned southern allies with their giant beasts or the orcs for that matter never show any tenderness. They are incapable of finer feeling because finer feeling is the birthright of the attractive elves.

Even the hobbits seem to "know their place" and to rank themselves as a people below the station of elves. How is this not racist?

I could understand if you would say that there are signs that Tolkien is not racist, but to say OF COURSE is to dismiss all the signs that he ranked people and creatures by race.

[Reply][61]

sheerahkahn says:

[ April 29, 2014 at 6:12 pm][62]

Zorg,
perhaps you should back it up a bit, and realized that by the time Tolkien was confronted with this request everyone knew the environment that Jew’s were confronted with in Germany. Tolkien was taking that moment to poke the hornets nest by lifting up the Jewish race when the subject of the inquiry was for him to distant himself from them.
Mayhaps, and I only suggest this as something to be considered…that you are projecting your own insecurities on Tolkien’s intentions.
As for Tolkien’s writing…he made no such comparisons between real life peoples and LotR races…

In his writing’s Americans could be Orc’s just as much as the Germans could have been…he was anti-industry…which is what the Orc’s represented…progress through technological innovation. Not a race being re-imagined as foul and craven, no…but representative of what he found to be wrong and destructive.

Sadly, too many people think like you do and render Mr. Tolkien’s writing little more than cudgels to beat your own drum with.

[Reply][63]

Marianne Ross says:

[ April 29, 2014 at 10:55 pm][64]

Great stuff! I love Tolkien’s unwavering response.

I’m not sure if you found the source there, but a very similar post was published on the Bully Pulpit a few months ago with some further details…

http://jrbenjamin.com/2014/01/24/j-r-r-tolkien-tells-off-the-nazis/

[Reply][65]

Zork says:

[ April 29, 2014 at 11:17 pm][66]

Zorg, the Jews are a gifted people. They constitute about .05 percent of humanity and maybe 2 percent of Americans, yet 20 percent of Nobel laureates are Jewish, about half of the chess grandmasters, etc. etc. etc. It is not racist to say that because Jews are not a race, they are a religio-ethnic culture which includes many (gifted) converts.

(Google "Mark Twain on the Jews".)

Nonetheless, Sheerahkahn’s reply that Tolkien was taking a stab at Nazi pride, is correct.

[Reply][67]

Geo says:

[ April 30, 2014 at 2:33 am][68]

He should have signed it as J.R.R. Trollkien,it would be more appropriate :)

[Reply][69]

Purva Agarwala says:

[ June 30, 2014 at 12:39 pm][70]

You know you can’t really write a piece on one of the most gifted writers, tag the article under Literature and then draft a sentence with "had almost became" – It’s a sin.

[Reply][71]

Lazlov3048 says:

[ December 6, 2014 at 3:14 am][72]

Tolkien was anti-German and his reply is childish and a rant.

The German publisher wanted to publish a German version of the Tolkien books. The German people loved this mythological stuff.

All the publisher did, in typical German orderly fashion, was to ask a legal requirement which was necessary to ask to publish books in Germany. If Tolkien was non-Aryan, it would pose a problem to mass publish this book for reading in Germany.

Tolkien’s reply was a childish rant. He should have replied "Yes" and been more sensible and think of the German readers who would be denied his work.

Of course he didnt care because he despised Germans are subhumans. Ironically he was more racist than Nazis here.

[Reply][73]

Bayzent says:

[ July 25, 2015 at 9:44 am][74]

I don’t think he did think of the Germans as subhumans, after all he did write:

"I have been accustomed, nonetheless, to regard my German name with pride, and continued to do so throughout the period of the late regrettable war, in which I served in the English army."

Like the huge majority of Britons and Americans back in the day he didn’t have much hatred for Germans despite having a lot of reasons for despising them. He seemed to have the same rightful ire against Himmler’s attempts to rewrite German history that most intellectuals who knew one or two things about real history had at the time, combined by his despise of Industrialism which, the Nazis technically agreed with (Blut und Boden and all that trash), which didn’t make him more hateful of the Germans than it did of the British, French and even Americans.

As for racism I cannot say, he was South African after all and in a time where even the Americans didn’t let blacks use the same services whites did, so he probably didn’t have many progressive views on race relations compared to nowadays, that said with the Hobbit and other books he seemed to believe strongly on Herzt’s Zionist ideas, so at least we know he wasn’t as antisemite as most of his contemporanies.

[Reply][75]

Corsair_Caruso says:

[ March 11, 2016 at 8:20 am][76]

Lazlov, your statement is not reflecting of an accurate understanding of Tolkien’s life, history, and professional work. Tolkien was proud of his Germanic heritage, keeping his German surname in a time when many English people of German descent were altering their surnames. He adored Germanic literature, myths, and languages, working nearly exclusively with them in his research and scholarly publications. His fantasy literature drew heavily from the Germanic mythos, especially "The Lord of the Rings" and "The Silmarillion." Though he fought against German soldiers in WWI, he had no special hatred of Germans. He hated Hitler and the bellicose and racist policies of the Third Reich, but that hatred did not extend to the German general population or culture. Your statement of 12/6/14 is simply incorrect.

[Reply][77]

HawkFest says:

[ September 25, 2016 at 1:53 am][78]

We’re not talking about your own ethnocentric and wishful thoughts in the matter, but about Tolkien’s. What you’re saying is already a preconceived evidence for most if not all of us. There was a context for the german people to become, quite understandably, highly sensible psychologically, hence "intellectually malleable". More generally and as for many other countries in the World, especially today in our so-called (corrupted) democracies, the acts of some idiots at the Helm don’t necessarily reflect the underlying potential and reality as a People.

Get over it. Please don’t project your own fears and ethnocentric paranoia on such discussion, it’s useless and it looks like some bait-and-switch throwing away the topic (rude). In short, you’re saying «It’s more complicated»… Of course it is when one’s identity is involved! Like a mix of emotions and contradictions one needs to rationalize in some way.. My suggestion: don’t try, let it be in the past. We can analyze how those methods to condition the masses were put at work, make parallels with today for that sole matter, but for the rest it’s part of our human experiences now: another proof that we’re the sole specie engaged into a somewhat "Extra-Biological" Evolution, involving our brain (relatively huge which is quite unique among other living species).

[Reply][79]

HawkFest says:

[ September 25, 2016 at 1:58 am][80]

That last reply was to Cody…

[Reply][81]

Name (required)

Email (required)

Message

[Click here to cancel reply.][82]

Wordpress Hashcash needs javascript to work, but your browser has javascript disabled. Your comment will be queued in Akismet!

Essentials
- [1,300 Free Online Courses][83]
- [1000+ MOOCs][84]
- [1,150 Free Movies][85]
- [700 Free Audio Books][86]
- [800 Free eBooks][87]
- [200 Free Textbooks][88]
- [300 Free Language Lessons][89]
- [150 Free Business Courses][90]
- [Free K-12 Education][91]
- [Get Our Daily Email][92]
Support Us

We're hoping to rely on loyal readers, rather than erratic ads. Click the Donate button and support Open Culture. We thank you!

![][49]

Free Courses
- [Astronomy][93]
- [Biology][94]
- [Business][90]
- [Chemistry][95]
- [Classics/Ancient World][96]
- [Computer Science][97]
- [Economics][98]
- [Engineering][99]
- [Environment][100]
- [History][101]
- [Literature][102]
- [Math][103]
- [Philosophy][104]
- [Physics][105]
- [Political Science][106]
- [Psychology][107]
- [Religion][108]
- [All 1250 Free Courses][83]
- [1000+ MOOCs & Certificate Courses][84]
- Free Movies
  - [1150 Free Movies Online][85]
  - [Free Film Noir][109]
  - [Silent Films][110]
  - [Documentaries][111]
  - [Martial Arts/Kung Fu][112]
  - [Animations][113]
  - [Free Hitchcock Films][114]
  - [Free Charlie Chaplin][115]
  - [Free John Wayne Movies][116]
  - [Free Tarkovsky Films][117]
  - [Free Dziga Vertov][118]
  - [Free Oscar Winners][119]
- Free Language Lessons
  - [Arabic][120]
  - [Chinese][121]
  - [English][122]
  - [French][123]
  - [German][124]
  - [Italian][125]
  - [Russian][126]
  - [Spanish][127]
  - [All Languages][128]
Free eBooks
- [700 Free eBooks][87]
- [Free Philosophy eBooks][129]
- [The Harvard Classics][130]
- [Philip K. Dick Stories][131]
- [Neil Gaiman Stories][132]
- [David Foster Wallace Stories & Essays][133]
- [Hemingway Stories][134]
- [Great Gatsby & Other Fitzgerald Novels][135]
- [HP Lovecraft][136]
- [Edgar Allan Poe][137]
- [Free Alice Munro Stories][138]
- [Jennifer Egan Stories][139]
- [George Saunders Stories][140]
- [Hunter S. Thompson Essays][141]
- [Joan Didion Essays][142]
- [Gabriel Garcia Marquez Stories][143]
- [David Sedaris Stories][144]
- [Stephen King][145]
- [Chomsky][146]
- [Golden Age Comics][147]
- [Free Books by UC Press][148]
- [Life Changing Books][149]
Free Audio Books
- [700 Free Audio Books][86]
- [Free Audio Books: Fiction][150]
- [Free Audio Books: Poetry][151]
- [Free Audio Books: Non-Fiction][152]
Free Textbooks
- [200 Free Textbooks][88]
- [Free Physics Textbooks][153]
- [Free Computer Science Textbooks][154]
- [Free Math Textbooks][155]
K-12 Resources
- [Free Books][156]
- [Free Video Lessons][157]
- [Web Resources by Subject][158]
- [Free Language Lessons][159]
- [Quality YouTube Channels][160]
- [Teacher Resources][161]
- [Test Prep][162]
- [All Free Kids Resources][91]
Free Art & Images
- [All Art Images & Books][163]
- [The Met][164]
- [The Getty][165]
- [The Rijksmuseum][166]
- [Smithsonian][167]
- [The Guggenheim][168]
- [The Tate][169]
- [The National Gallery][170]
- [The Whitney][171]
- [LA County Museum][172]
- [Stanford University][173]
- [British Library][174]
- [Google Art Project][175]
- [French Revolution][176]
- [Getty Images][177]
- [Guggenheim Art Books][178]
- [Met Art Books][179]
- [Getty Art Books][180]
- [New York Public Library Maps][181]
- [Museum of New Zealand][182]
- [Street Art][183]
- [Smarthistory][184]
- [Rembrandt][185]
- [Van Gogh][186]
- [Coloring Books][187]
Free Music
- [All Bach Organ Works][188]
- [All of Bach][189]
- [80,000 Classical Music Scores][190]
- [Free Classical Music][191]
- [Live Classical Music][192]
- [9,000 Grateful Dead Concerts][193]
- [Alan Lomax Blues & Folk Archive][194]
Writing Tips
- [Hemingway][195]
- [Fitzgerald][196]
- [Stephen King][197]
- [Ray Bradbury][198]
- [William Zinsser][199]
- [Kurt Vonnegut][200]
- [Toni Morrison][201]
- [Edgar Allan Poe][202]
- [Margaret Atwood][203]
- [David Ogilvy][204]
- [Steinbeck][205]
- [Billy Wilder][206]
Archive
- [All posts by date][207]
Categories
- [Amazon Kindle][208]
- [Animation][209]
- [Apple][210]
- [Architecture][211]
- [Archives][212]
- [Art][213]
- [Astronomy][214]
- [Audio Books][215]
- [Beat & Tweets][216]
- [Biology][217]
- [Books][218]
- [Business][219]
- [Chemistry][220]
- [Comedy][221]
- [Comics/Cartoons][222]
- [Computer Science][223]
- [Creativity][224]
- [Current Affairs][225]
- [Dance][226]
- [Data][227]
- [Deals][228]
- [Design][229]
- [e-books][230]
- [Economics][231]
- [Education][232]
- [English Language][233]
- [Entrepreneurship][234]
- [Environment][235]
- [Film][236]
- [Food & Drink][237]
- [Games][238]
- [Gender][239]
- [Google][240]
- [Graduation Speech][241]
- [Harvard][242]
- [Health][243]
- [History][244]
- [How to Learn for Free][245]
- [Internet Archive][246]
- [iPad][247]
- [iPhone][248]
- [Jazz][249]
- [K-12][250]
- [Language Lessons][251]
- [Law][252]
- [Letters][253]
- [Life][254]
- [Literature][11]
- [Magazines][255]
- [Maps][256]
- [Math][257]
- [Media][258]
- [MIT][259]
- [MOOCs][260]
- [Most Popular][261]
- [Museums][262]
- [Music][263]
- [Nature][264]
- [Neuroscience][265]
- [Online Courses][266]
- [Opera][267]
- [Philosophy][268]
- [Photography][269]
- [Physics][270]
- [Podcast Articles and Resources][271]
- [Poetry][272]
- [Politics][273]
- [Psychology][274]
- [Radio][275]
- [Random][276]
- [Religion][277]
- [Sci Fi][278]
- [Science][279]
- [Software][280]
- [Sports][281]
- [Stanford][282]
- [Technology][283]
- [TED Talks][284]
- [Television][285]
- [Theatre][286]
- [Travel][287]
- [Twitter][288]
- [UC Berkeley][289]
- [Uncategorized][290]
- [Video – Arts & Culture][291]
- [Video – Politics/Society][292]
- [Video – Science][293]
- [Video Games][294]
- [Web/Tech][295]
- [Wikipedia][296]
- [Writing][297]
- [Yale][298]
- [YouTube][299]
Great Lectures
- [Michel Foucault][300]
- [Sun Ra at UC Berkeley][301]
- [Richard Feynman][302]
- [Joseph Campbell][303]
- [Carl Sagan][304]
- [Margaret Atwood][305]
- [Jorge Luis Borges][306]
- [Leonard Bernstein][307]
- [Richard Dawkins][308]
- [Buckminster Fuller][309]
- [Walter Kaufmann on Existentialism][310]
- [Jacques Lacan][311]
- [Roland Barthes][312]
- [Nobel Lectures by Writers][313]
- [Toni Morrison][314]
- [Bertrand Russell][315]
- [Oxford Philosophy Lectures][316]
FREE UPDATES!

GET OUR DAILY EMAIL

Get the best cultural and educational resources on the web curated for you in a daily email. We never spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

FOLLOW ON SOCIAL MEDIA

* __
* __
* __
* __

About Us

![][317]

Open Culture editor [Dan Colman][318] scours the web for the best educational media. He finds the free courses and audio books you need, the language lessons & movies you want, and plenty of enlightenment in between.

[Advertise With Us][319]

Great Recordings
- [T.S. Eliot Reads Waste Land][320]
- [Sylvia Plath - Ariel][321]
- [Joyce Reads Ulysses][322]
- [Joyce - Finnegans Wake][323]
- [Patti Smith Reads Virginia Woolf][324]
- [Albert Einstein][325]
- [Charles Bukowski][326]
- [Bill Murray][327]
- [Hemingway][328]
- [Fitzgerald Reads Shakespeare][329]
- [William Faulkner][330]
- [Flannery O'Connor][331]
- [Tolkien - The Hobbit][332]
- [Allen Ginsberg - Howl][333]
- [W.B Yeats][334]
- [Ezra Pound][335]
- [Dylan Thomas][336]
- [Anne Sexton][337]
- [John Cheever][338]
- [David Foster Wallace][339]
Book Lists By
- [Neil deGrasse Tyson][340]
- [Ernest Hemingway][341]
- [F. Scott Fitzgerald][342]
- [Allen Ginsberg][343]
- [Patti Smith][344]
- [Brian Eno][345]
- [Henry Miller][346]
- [Christopher Hitchens][347]
- [Joseph Brodsky][348]
- [W.H. Auden][349]
- [Donald Barthelme][350]
- [Carl Sagan][351]
- [David Bowie][352]
- [Samuel Beckett][353]
- [Art Garfunkel][354]
- [Marilyn Monroe][355]
- [Jorge Luis Borges][356]
- [Picks by Female Creatives][357]
- Syllabi
  - [WH Auden][349]
  - [David Foster Wallace][358]
  - [Donald Barthelme][350]
  - [Allen Ginsberg][343]
  - [Zadie Smith & Gary Shteyngart][359]
  - [Spike Lee][360]
  - [Lynda Barry][361]
  - [Junot Diaz][362]
Favorite Movies
- [Kubrick][363]
- [Kurosawa's 100][364]
- [Tarantino][365]
- [Scorsese][366]
- [Tarkovsky][367]
- [David Lynch][368]
- [Werner Herzog][369]
- [Woody Allen][370]
- [Wes Anderson][371]
- [Luis Buñuel][372]
- [Roger Ebert][373]
- [Susan Sontag][374]
- [Scorsese Foreign Films][375]
- [Philosophy Films][376]
Archives
- [February 2018][377]
- [January 2018][378]
- [December 2017][379]
- [November 2017][380]
- [October 2017][381]
- [September 2017][382]
- [August 2017][383]
- [July 2017][384]
- [June 2017][385]
- [May 2017][386]
- [April 2017][387]
- [March 2017][388]
- [February 2017][389]
- [January 2017][390]
- [December 2016][391]
- [November 2016][392]
- [October 2016][393]
- [September 2016][394]
- [August 2016][395]
- [July 2016][396]
- [June 2016][397]
- [May 2016][398]
- [April 2016][399]
- [March 2016][400]
- [February 2016][401]
- [January 2016][402]
- [December 2015][403]
- [November 2015][404]
- [October 2015][405]
- [September 2015][406]
- [August 2015][407]
- [July 2015][408]
- [June 2015][409]
- [May 2015][410]
- [April 2015][411]
- [March 2015][412]
- [February 2015][413]
- [January 2015][414]
- [December 2014][415]
- [November 2014][416]
- [October 2014][417]
- [September 2014][418]
- [August 2014][419]
- [July 2014][420]
- [June 2014][421]
- [May 2014][422]
- [April 2014][423]
- [March 2014][424]
- [February 2014][425]
- [January 2014][426]
- [December 2013][427]
- [November 2013][428]
- [October 2013][429]
- [September 2013][430]
- [August 2013][431]
- [July 2013][432]
- [June 2013][433]
- [May 2013][434]
- [April 2013][435]
- [March 2013][436]
- [February 2013][437]
- [January 2013][438]
- [December 2012][439]
- [November 2012][440]
- [October 2012][441]
- [September 2012][442]
- [August 2012][443]
- [July 2012][444]
- [June 2012][445]
- [May 2012][446]
- [April 2012][447]
- [March 2012][448]
- [February 2012][449]
- [January 2012][450]
- [December 2011][451]
- [November 2011][452]
- [October 2011][453]
- [September 2011][454]
- [August 2011][455]
- [July 2011][456]
- [June 2011][457]
- [May 2011][458]
- [April 2011][459]
- [March 2011][460]
- [February 2011][461]
- [January 2011][462]
- [December 2010][463]
- [November 2010][464]
- [October 2010][465]
- [September 2010][466]
- [August 2010][467]
- [July 2010][468]
- [June 2010][469]
- [May 2010][470]
- [April 2010][471]
- [March 2010][472]
- [February 2010][473]
- [January 2010][474]
- [December 2009][475]
- [November 2009][476]
- [October 2009][477]
- [September 2009][478]
- [August 2009][479]
- [July 2009][480]
- [June 2009][481]
- [May 2009][482]
- [April 2009][483]
- [March 2009][484]
- [February 2009][485]
- [January 2009][486]
- [December 2008][487]
- [November 2008][488]
- [October 2008][489]
- [September 2008][490]
- [August 2008][491]
- [July 2008][492]
- [June 2008][493]
- [May 2008][494]
- [April 2008][495]
- [March 2008][496]
- [February 2008][497]
- [January 2008][498]
- [December 2007][499]
- [November 2007][500]
- [October 2007][501]
- [September 2007][502]
- [August 2007][503]
- [July 2007][504]
- [June 2007][505]
- [May 2007][506]
- [April 2007][507]
- [March 2007][508]
- [February 2007][509]
- [January 2007][510]
- [December 2006][511]
- [November 2006][512]
- [October 2006][513]
- [September 2006][514]

![][515]

Home
[About Us][516]
[Advertise with Us][319]
[Copyright Policy ][517]
[Privacy Policy ][518]
[Terms of Use][519]
[Bio][520]
Audio Books
Online Courses
MOOCs
Movies
Languages
Textbooks
eBooks
__
__
__
__

![Quantcast][521]

Do you want more open culture?

if you like our Facebook fanpage, you'll receive more articles like the one you just read!

Do you already like us on Facebook?

[Do not ask me again for Facebook][16]

[Continue to the article »][16]

85 KiB Raw Blame History Unescape Escape

J.R.R. Tolkien Snubs a German Publisher Asking for Proof of His "Aryan Descent" (1938) | Open Culture

[J.R.R. Tolkien Snubs a German Publisher Asking for Proof of His "Aryan Descent" (1938)][10]

Comments (16)

Leave a Reply

Essentials

Support Us

Free Courses

Free Movies

Free Language Lessons

Free eBooks

Free Audio Books

Free Textbooks

K-12 Resources

Free Art & Images

Free Music

Writing Tips

Archive

Categories

Great Lectures

FREE UPDATES!

GET OUR DAILY EMAIL

About Us

Great Recordings

Book Lists By

Syllabi

Favorite Movies

Archives

85 KiB

Raw Blame History